|

A pilot implementation study has been planned to make a
practical test of the VITEK assessment methodology in real-life field
situations. The main purpose of the pilot study is to evaluate the feasibility,
practicality, efficiency, and reliability of the method defined in section
6 of this report. This type of exercise will be useful for identifying
and correcting any errors, weaknesses or problems with the different operations
that make up the protocol. The first phases of the pilot study will be
financed with annual research funds that are granted to the project's
PI by his home institution, the Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones
Científicas (IVIC). Application for additional funding will be
made to the Ley Orgánica de Ciencia, Tecnología e Innovación
(LOCTI) program sponsored by the Ministerio del Poder Popular para Ciencia
y Tecnología, República Bolivariana de Venezuela.
Ideally, the pilot study should be done among a sample of diverse groups
located in different ecoregions in different countries. However, due mainly
to economic and logistical constraints as well as prior commitments, we
are proposing to do a first phase of testing entirely in Venezuela, which
is the country of residence of the project's PI. The plan is to implement
it among four different biocultural groups that represent a range of variation
in terms of bio-ecological setting, economic orientation, ethnic composition,
degree of acculturation, and linguistic situation. The four groups tentatively
chosen for the study include: (1) the Yabarana,
(2) the Jotï, (3) the communities
of Cuyagua and Chuao, and (4) the communities
of Apure and Acequias. Besides the fact that they encompass a considerable
range of socioecological variation, a primary criterion used for their
selection is that the PI of this report or members of his research group
at IVIC have had previous contacts and/or field experience with all of
them, which should facilitate access and receptivity. A brief description
of each group is provided below.
1) The Yabarana are an indigenous group
living in the Manapiare and Parucito River Basins of Amazonas State. The
Yabarana population comprises approximately 300 persons distributed in
seven ethnically mixed communities (besides Yabarana, these are mainly
Piaroa, Panare, Yekuana and mestizo).The local environment consists of
a mosaic of seasonally flooded savanna, lowland tropical forest, premontane
forest, tepuy table mountains, blackwater rivers and creeks, and lagoons.
The main economic activities include shifting cultivation, fishing, hunting,
collection of nontimber forest products, cattle ranching, and occasional
placer gold mining. According to written as well as oral history, the
land area currently occupied by the Yabarana is considered to be their
ancestral territory but both the population as well as their geographical
range has been reduced during the last three centuries of colonization
and state expansion. The Yabarana suffered demographic and economic shocks
during the rubber boom period: some subgroups were coerced into debt-peonage
extractive labor while others fled the collection zones and hid from the
rubber bosses and their gangs. Other indigenous and nonindigenous groups
have moved into this region, especially during the past 50 years, and
the Yabarana have experienced a high degree of interethnic marriage and
diffusion of foreign cultural elements. One result of this history of
cultural and biological assimilation is that the Yabarana language is
no longer spoken actively by the majority of the population; the main
languages spoken in Yabarana communities today being Spanish and Piaroa.
Despite these changes, the Yabarana maintain a strong sense of ethnic
identity and have formed a tribal organization which has undertaken activities
aimed at recuperating some of their lands occupied by outsiders and revitalizing
their cultural and linguistic traditions.
2) The Jotï are an indigenous group
numbering about 800 individuals among 25 communities located in the Upper
Cuchivero watershed in Bolívar State, and the Asita, Iguana, and
Upper Parucito River basins in Amazonas State. The local environment is
mainly tropical forest that varies in terms of structure and composition
along an altitudinal gradient from basimontane to premontane to montane
levels. The Jotï were totally isolated and uncontacted by the western
world until the 1970's due to the difficult access and rugged mountainous
terrain of their home territory. At that time, they were very nomadic
and subsisted mainly by hunting-gathering but also practiced an incipient
form of shifting cultivation. In the last three decades, some of them
have expanded their contacts with neighboring indigenous groups and foreign
missionaries, acquired western trade goods and tools, and been exposed
to foreign cultural beliefs and practices. However, not all local groups
are equally affected by these changes. Some groups continue to live a
traditional nomadic lifestyle and have virtually no contact with nonJotï
and even those who have settled around current or former mission bases
still have very limited contact and interaction with outsiders and continue
to depend heavily on foraging and trekking activities for their livelihood.
As a result, the Jotï are rightly considered to be one of the least
acculturated indigenous groups living in Venezuela today. Most members
of their group are monolingual speakers of the Jotï language and
relatively few people have learned Spanish as a second language.
3) The residents of Chuao and Cuyagua municipalities
constitute a criollo (i.e. mestizo) population of mixed Indian, African,
and European ancestry occupying a coastal habitat. These communities are
located in fluvial valleys on the northern coast of Aragua State, bordered
on the north by the Caribbean Sea and on the south by the Cordillera de
la Costa (coastal mountain range). Besides the sea, beach and littoral
scrublands, this region encompasses humid premontane forest, low montane
forest, and dry tropical forest life zones. Chuao and Cuyagua were founded
as colonial plantation settlements in the XVIth and XVIIth centuries respectively
in an area occupied by Carib and Arawakan Indians. African slaves were
brought in from the XVIIIth century on to supply labor for agricultural
works, mainly cocoa, indigo and coffee production, and intermarried over
the years with the Indian population. This area was only accessible by
boat or foot travel until the 1960's and, partly as a consequence of its
relative isolation, the inhabitants developed a distinctive regional expressive
culture characterized by syncretic religious beliefs, cycle of Catholic-based
fiestas, cofradía (brotherhood) organizations, herbal- and faith-based
healing, and African-rooted music and dance. The main economic activities
practiced in both localities are: commercial silviculture dominated by
cocoa or coffee, family subsistence gardens, maritime fishing, tourism-related
businesses, construction, and government-sector jobs. A fairly large number
of young adults have moved to cities in the northern states in order to
perform wage labor, and send periodic remittances home to older as well
as younger relatives still living in the communities. Everyone in both
communities speaks Spanish as their mother tongue.
4) The agricultural peasant communities of Apure
and Acequias, located in the Sierra Nevada of Mérida State,
comprise a mestizo group with European and Indian biological and cultural
roots. The local environment corresponds to high mountain ecosystems between
2,000 and 4,000 m asl, including cloud forest, subparamo, and paramo life
zones, in addition to substantial human-altered expanses. This region
was originally inhabited by the once numerous but now-extinct Timoto-Cuica
Indian group but it was converted into a major wheat- and dairy-producing
region by the colonial authorities beginning in the XVIIth century. Over
a period of centuries, the native population and culture either declined
or merged with incoming European settlers. Today the region's inhabitants
resemble in many respects other peasants throughout the Andean mountain
region of Venezuela except that they are notorious for their cultural
conservatism and insularity. Agriculture continues to be the economic
mainstay, of which different types of crop farming are practiced (e.g.
maize, wheat, potato, carrots, dairy - varying mainly according to altitude
and topography) for home consumption as well as for sale. Numerous wild
plant species are also collected for medicinal and technological purposes.
No one in this area speaks an Indian language anymore, although a number
of indigenous words still survive, especially the names of plants, animals,
and places.
Community members will have an active role for implementation of the
proposed methodology. First, they will be responsible for determining
the specific content of the local corpus of TEK that they consider to
be valid, viable, and valuable (section 6.2). Second, certain members
will be trained to administer the testing instrument, to code the data
collected, and to report the results to designated data managers (section
6.3). Following implementation of the methodology and collection of data,
indices will be produced for all four groups (section 6.4). Based on the
results of this experience, the methodology will be critically evaluated
and necessary modifications will be made at that time. |